But it's OK now. I read RBBOT's HTML table masterclass post from earlier in this thread and am quite happy now with my own tables. Not as spiffing as your one but good enough I reckon and input all saved so I can use for further information over time.
Interesting to see how the averages differ - it seems that those of us who only predicted on this were more optimistic for Heather and Naomi C, and less so for Katie and Anne. And I like the general optimism for the men on the other thread!
My predictions were rubbish. Managed to predict 2 retirements but got the names of the players wrong. Naomi Broady seems to be the player who out-performed the predictions on the whole. Bally has also done a bit better than most expected. Far too optimistic on Tara and Mel.
-- Edited by kundalini on Wednesday 26th of October 2011 01:08:57 PM
I wasn't going to predict but actually I'd like to see who posts closest to the reality at the end of the season... Bally - all depends on how she starts the season (and injuries), if she can get through some good matches at the first few events, I'll think she'll keep improving. But with so many new points to defend I don't think there will be much progress on the ranking - 60. Anne - I'm slightly more optimistic with Anne. I do wish she would change her coach though, she needs to take a risk, mix it up a little and try something different. She doesn't win enough of her own service games and she looks shakey under pressure. However, if she can start well I hope we'll see her creep up the ranking again - 80. Heather - the NEW great hope. I'm not convinced she has a game that can scratch the top 20 but I think she'll progress to being a good GB top 40 player. This year though it's as much about individual results as ranking. I think with a good grass court season we could see her in the top 100. I'm going out on a limb and predict 80. Laura - event restrictions limits opportunity. But again, for Laura this year is about big scalps and a good grass court season, not ranking. If by the end of the season she's top 200 that will put her in a great position to assualt the top player come 2012. I hope we'll see her finish 150. Cav - too inconsistent. 200 Katie - lost it, no weapons and too many AO points to defend. 220. Naomi - again, too inconsistent and not showing enough for me. 230. Tara - shame about the funding. If she can stay fit I'm going 200. Mel - who knows, impossible to read, I think she'll make small but positive progress 210.
Not too far off Bally, Anne, Laura and Heather. Lend me your crystal ball I want to buy a Euromillions ticket
Great to hear Anna may be back! Hopefully Jos as well sometime....
Slightly o/t, but the competition planners for next year are now up on the LTA site, all tournament values are exactly the same on the womens' side at least, except for the 2nd (Bath) event in March has been downgraded to a 10k from a 25k. Also to note, from the ITF, that the long-lived Sutton 25k is no more - the 2 January 10ks will now be Glasgow & Sutton, with the 25k in Sunderland.
According to her twitter feed Jos had an operation 2 weeks ago 'to remove a fractured bone' (?) in her foot. Don't know how long it takes to recover from this but I wish her a speedy recovery as it would be great to see her back on court.
Maybe a bit late about this, but better late than never as they say. If Albino reads this, I would be greatly indebted if he would be so kind to update with the final rankings as of 26/12. I think it would be fair to withdraw both Naomi C and Anna S from the final table but keep Katie ( ret ) in it as per the other predictions thread.
The table above shows how far out each prediction was, with a red number being an optimistic prediciton and a black number pessimistic. The last 2 columns show an average "distance away" for each participants predicitions. As everyone predicted that Joko, Tara, Mel, KoB, Anna F and Lisa would finish higher than they did, I also did an average of just the top 5 women. Thegingerlightbulb deserves a special mention for predicting 4 players within 3 positions of their final ranking!
The table, with it's positive and negative colouring, does really starkly show how well the top 5 have generally done as against our expectations, and how distinctly not so well what were looked on as the next group of players have done. If we take account of Naomi C and Anna S not being there at all ( through retiral and injury ) we have not had anything like what we hoped in the sort of WR 200 to 400 range. Good though to see how, separately from these predictions, Emily W-S and Sam Murray have done, and Eleanor Dean at a lower level. Tara although not advancing as folk had hoped had a very encouraging last 2 or 3 months in 2011.
But certainly the good in 2011 was our top players, who really did have a good year. I think that is what's most important, and swung most folk who responded in the thread about this women's season to consider it to have been a good season and better than 2010.
But let's have more players stepping up to the plate, advancing further or recapturing some of their former form in 2012 !
Thanks Albino !!. As far as I can see Reeltime is the overall winner for all those that predicted all the 11 players, so congratulations to him. Yes it was a tough year for the chasing pack, so plenty of work to be done in 2012. There are excuses for JoKo, Anna F and Lisa who had injury problems, but Tara for whom I had the least positive prediction for 2011 does look in a very strong position to make up for it in 2012. Mel to me looks the only real standout disappointment given that she was basically injury free for the whole of 2011.